"Once, I visited a youth festival and found myself sitting beside another politician. He was grasping a pile of 100 baht notes to hand out to the children, while I had come without gifts. How was I supposed to contend with that?"
The politician Chutiphong was a member of the "orange wave" of idealistic young candidates who surprised Thailand in the last national poll by winning more seats for the reformist political group than any rival party.
This year though, he lost his seat in his home province of Rayong to a opponent from an old established family which has customarily occupied influential posts there.
"Back then we were like a storm that engulfed and the rival factions were unprepared to counter. They thought I was only a obscure candidate. The wave of support for Move Forward in the closing stages of that election genuinely persuaded voters to opt for something new."
Now renamed the People's Party, their aspirations that they would surpass their 2023 performance were shattered on the reefs of old-style patronage networks which have governed local politics in Thailand during its modern history.
The results are not yet official, and a series of election issues are being examined, but that cannot reverse the final picture: a dramatic drop of over 20% in the total of seats won by the People's Party, and a remarkable surge by the traditionalist Bhumjaithai party, boosting its share of seats from 71 in 2023 to an approximate 193 in the 500-seat parliament in the latest election.
'They ceased to address me after that'
After securing his seat in 2023, Chutiphong immersed himself in his role as MP, travelling around his district hoping to help solve the issues of his constituents. But he rapidly faced pushback from those loyal to the established power-brokers. Furthermore, he realized he was required to make substantial contributions, from resources he just did not have.
"I was invited to a female empowerment event - a frequent function for the residents to join and socialize. But they said if I wished to come, I had to give 25,000 baht. I explained I lacked that money. They were extremely disappointed about that and said I was stingy. I inquired if there was something else I could do to help out. But they never spoke to me afterwards."
What he had run up against was a deep-rooted framework of patronage dominated by a single family.
Rayong is best known as a component of the Eastern Economic Corridor, Thailand's biggest manufacturing hub, containing many of the factories which fuel its export-dependent economy. This has drawn migrant workers from across the country, and also led to an urban middle class which is more receptive to the progressive policies of the reformist groups.
In 2023, Move Forward swept all five constituencies there.
But much of Rayong is remains rural, home to agricultural workers and fruit growers. This is especially the case in District 4, where Chutipong won his seat. He is a native son, but lived a number of years based in California. The province has for decades been ruled by a single powerful clan, the Pitutecha family. This is what is termed in Thailand as "Baan Yai" – big house – politics, and across the country it is the method local power has traditionally been exercised.
Pitutechas run much of the regional authority.
Piya 'Chang' Pitutecha, the sitting patriarch, is the selected chief of the Provincial Administration Organisation (PAO), a hugely influential position as the PAO manages the majority of official budgets in Rayong.
Prior to 2023, Pitutechas had consistently been counted among the MPs chosen to parliament, with one serving as the vice-minister for health in Bangkok.
Similar to other "Baan Yai" dynasties they have no particular loyalty – through the years they have been members of several political parties. They are also influential in the area's economy, and, in contrast to Chutipong, have plenty of financial resources to hand out. It was practically impossible for the rookie MP to challenge.
The "Big House" depend on extensive systems of canvassers - residents who understand their neighbourhoods, and who organize voters to back their candidate. And although it is officially forbidden, they also hand out money before, during, and after elections. They have always been crucial to the success of provincial hopefuls, and as a recent, predominantly metropolitan movement, the People's Party had no access to them.
"So I changed my approach," states Chutipong. "I stated that I would attempt to address all grievances promptly. If your water doesn't run, your electricity isn't on, your road has potholes, I would assist."
"But the locals who sought my help then faced coercion from the local machine. Some got criticised in the village's chat group or over the PA system in the village. They were accused of allowing me - an intruder they said - into the area."
"On occasions when I attempted to investigate factories after hearing some allegations about environmental damage, I faced a hostile response from nearby residents because they had been receiving envelopes from these factories."
During the recent electoral contest, the Pitutechas had adapted after their loss in the previous election.
In those electoral areas, they nominated junior members of the family, better educated and with less of patriarchal aura than the established figures. In District 3 they ran under the Democrat party, historically their chosen political partner, but in District 4, 34-year-old Chatchai Pitutecha ran under Prime Minister Anutin Charvirakul's Bhumjaithai party, known for its substantial resources and its ability in recruiting "Big House" to his side.
Chutipong was outgunned.
The Pitutechas recaptured both seats back from the People's Party, although the the party kept three seats in Rayong.
"They might have welcomed me if I had given them money, but I could not do that forever due to my limited resources. I had to decide whether I would be the MP they demanded, or if I would keep my principles and find out if the voters would